Bathtub Refinishing vs. Replacement: Which Is the Better Choice for Your Home?

Bathtub refinishing vs. replacement—what’s the best option? If your bathtub looks worn, stained, or outdated, you might be wondering about this. Well you’ll want to read on because this article is for you.

Refinishing can restore your existing tub to look brand new at a fraction of the cost of replacement, while replacing the bathtub can provide a fresh start with a new style or material. But which one is right for you?

In this guide, we’ll compare cost, durability, time, and environmental impact to help you decide whether bathtub refinishing or replacement is the best choice for your home.

What Is Bathtub Refinishing?

Bathtub refinishing—also known as bathtub reglazing or resurfacing—is a process where the surface of an old bathtub is repaired and coated with a new durable finish.

🔹 Process:

1. The tub is thoroughly cleaned and stripped of old coatings.
2. Chips, scratches, and stains are repaired.
3. A high-quality refinishing material (such as an acrylic or polyurethane coating) is applied.
4. The surface is sealed, leaving a smooth, glossy, and durable finish.

🔹 Benefits of Bathtub Refinishing:
✔ Affordable (costs 70–80% less than replacement)
✔ Quick process (usually completed in one day)
✔ Eco-friendly (reduces landfill waste)
✔ Lasts 10–15 years with proper care

Average cost of bathtub refinishing: $450–$600

What Is Bathtub Replacement?

Bathtub replacement involves completely removing the old tub and installing a brand-new one. While this option allows you to choose a new style, material, or size, it also comes with higher costs and more time-consuming renovations.

🔹 Process:

1. Old bathtub is removed, often requiring demolition.
2. Plumbing adjustments may be needed for the new tub.
3. Surrounding walls, tiles, and flooring may require repairs.
4. The new bathtub is installed and sealed.

🔹 Benefits of Replacement:
✔ Option to change tub size, material, or design
✔ Ideal for severe damage or full remodels
✔ Can last decades if high-quality materials are used

Average cost of bathtub replacement: $1,500–$5,000+

Key Differences: Bathtub Refinishing vs. Replacement

1. Cost Comparison

One of the biggest deciding factors is cost.

• Refinishing costs between $300–$600, depending on the condition of the tub.
• Replacement costs $1,500–$5,000+, including labor, plumbing, and potential remodeling expenses.

If budget is a concern, bathtub refinishing is the clear winner.

2. Time & Convenience

• Refinishing takes only 1 day, allowing you to use your tub the next day.
• Replacement can take several days to weeks, depending on demolition, plumbing, and installation.

For a quick and hassle-free solution, refinishing is the better choice.

3. Durability & Longevity

• A refinished bathtub lasts 10–15 years with proper care
  • Keep your refinished but looking like new with our custom cleaning spray: Refinished
• A new bathtub can last 20+ years, but its lifespan depends on the material and maintenance.

If your existing bathtub is structurally sound, refinishing can give you many more years of use at a fraction of the cost.

4. Environmental Impact

• Refinishing reuses your existing tub, reducing landfill waste.
• Replacing a tub contributes to construction debris and waste, especially if tiles and flooring also need replacement.

For a more eco-friendly choice, bathtub refinishing is the better option.

When Should You Choose Refinishing?

✅ Your tub has minor stains, discoloration, or surface damage (chipping, scratches).
✅ You want a quick and cost-effective solution.
✅ You like the size and shape of your existing bathtub.
✅ You want to avoid major plumbing or remodeling work.

Refinishing is ideal for homeowners, landlords, and property managers looking for an affordable way to restore a bathtub.

When Should You Choose Replacement?

✅ Your bathtub has severe cracks, leaks, or rust that refinishing can’t fix.
✅ You’re planning a full bathroom remodel and want a different tub style.
✅ You want to increase your home’s resale value with a brand-new tub.

If your tub is beyond repair or you’re undergoing major renovations, replacement might be the better option.

Conclusion: Which Option Is Best for You?

When comparing bathtub refinishing vs. replacement, the best choice depends on your budget, timeline, and bathtub condition.

• Choose refinishing if you want a cost-effective, quick, and eco-friendly solution.
• Choose replacement if your tub has severe damage or you want a complete remodel.

For most homeowners, bathtub refinishing is the best option because it saves thousands of dollars, restores the tub’s appearance, and extends its lifespan.

Looking for a Professional Bathtub Refinishing Company?

If you’re considering refinishing your bathtub, trust an experienced professional for the best results. Contact Aarco Baths today for a free quote and transform your bathtub at a fraction of the cost of replacement!